More kids pitching.
Posted 11 December 2019 - 09:01 PM
They want to make rules in minors to get every kid pitching that wants to pitch....I say that’s a coaching problem, not a problem that we need to make rules to fix.
I also believe this will require a waiver, not a simple bylaw change.
>>MINORS By-Law changes/Additions
Minors Baseball is considered an instructional league and should be coached accordingly; players shall be provided instructions and taught to play more than one defensive position. All players should receive equal playing time and will play multiple positions within a game with at least one inning in the infield. The team on defense will have no more than 6 players in the infield and must have a catcher with regulation gear and a pitcher standing at the mound, and up to 3 players will play in the outfield.
1) No pitcher can pitch more than one (1) time without every other player on the team getting a chance to pitch.
a. Definition of a chance to pitch, is a player pitching to at least 1 batter to the completion of that at bat, or a verbal decline to pitch from the player to the umpire or official score keeper which will then be logged as that players chance to pitch.
2) If a Manager pitches a player more than once without giving all other players an opportunity to pitch the 1st time will be a warning and loss of one (1) Adult base coach for 1 game. 2nd time will be an ejection and 1 game suspension of the manager as well as a meeting with the board. 3RD time the Manager will be brought to the board for further disciplinary action up to removal from the league
Posted 11 December 2019 - 09:53 PM
“The team on defense will have no more than 6 players in the infield and must have a catcher with regulation gear and a pitcher standing at the mound, and up to 3 players will play in the outfield.”
Takes away a few shifts.
Posted 11 December 2019 - 10:53 PM
Actually, restricting pitchers to pitching LESS than what the rules allow, especially in minors, does not require a Waiver.
That said, making a rule that every kid has to pitch is, in my opinion, crazy.
It's tough enough in minors to find three/maybe four kids that can throw strikes, mandating all 12 kids pitch is nuts!
Basically the kids that can't pitch are going to pitch to one batter. Trot little Jimmy out to the mound, let him throw four balls then take him out. That should really make him feel good.
Of course with minors and a five run limit the manager can just take the worst 8-9 pitchers and let each of them pitch to one batter each in the first inning. With mostly walks you'd give up 4-5 runs but now your real pitchers can pitch!
By the way, how long would it take for 8 pitching changes in one inning?
Be careful what you wish for!
I also don't like mandating all players play one inning in the infield, for some kids that can be a Safety Issue. Heaven forbid a player gets seriously injured.
Equal playing time can be difficult, I know leagues that mandate 9 defensive outs rather than 6, that's easier to track/enforce.
Posted 12 December 2019 - 01:29 AM
Agree that minors is an instructional league - but this is overstepping the role of 'rules'. Some players just don't want to pitch. Others simply cannot throw strikes. How about a simple manager training and written guide which states:
Minors Baseball is considered an instructional league and should be coached accordingly
1) Players shall be provided instructions and taught to play multiple defensive positions.
2) Each player shall be positioned for approximately the same number of innings in the infield per game, and similarly in the outfield per game.
3) A players who arrives prior to the start of game shall sit out no more than two defensive innings per game.
4) All batting is continuous order and the player 'on deck' during the last at-bat should be the first batter of the following game.
5) Each pitcher may only pitch two innings per game and all players should be encouraged to try to pitch
Posted 12 December 2019 - 09:30 PM
I’m a no vote on the above but I’m pretty sure I’m in the minority so I’m looking for a compromise to bring to the next meeting.
Something along the lines of....Every kid that wants to pitch will be giving a minimum of one opportunity to pitch once in the first half of the season and once in the second half.
We would need a process for a kid to decline their opportunity or even the coach to claim safety risk
We would need to define opportunity so it’s not just to one batter and done.....20 pitches...two walks...or five batters....what ever comes first..?
..and we would need to define punishment for coaches...First half rule violation, sit out x amount of games....Second half violation, don’t come back next year (hard to enforce with different boards each year) ...or maybe can’t manage or coach tournament play..?
Thanks for all replies and help.
Posted 13 December 2019 - 06:04 PM
It is not for the Board to decide placement of players on the field. It is up to the Board to select Managers that are willing to manage the team, select coaches, and teach the players.
As a former Manager of 14 teams over 10 years I worked long hours to train and develop players' skills. My throwing warm-ups included all levels of close tossing, then backing up and twisting the body in certain positions to mimic throws on the field, then backing up as a fielder receiving a grounder and transitioning to a throw, then at the distance of a pitcher throwing the ball like a pitcher (but not at full velocity), then continuing back to long toss, then moving in on the run catching and throwing. That was just warm-up and everyone did it so they learned the pitching mechanics.
I had players that wanted to pitch that frankly could not throw the ball to another player on the field, let alone over the plate. I worked with player parents outside of practice with my boys as catchers to teach the entry level skills of a pitcher. How to hold the ball that works for them, how to stand, how to move your feet, move the arms, stride, plant, release, etc. My counterparts from other teams complained that I always had too many pitchers, but they later admitted that some of my pitchers did not tryout very well, but learned over time.
I had many players over the years that said they did NOT want to pitch, and their parents were fine with it. I still worked with them on the mechanics and almost all of them actually pitched for our teams and did fine. One player I remember very well was scared to death. He turned out to be an awesome closer, pitching one inning each time to perfection to close out several games. Ultimately I got him to be a starting pitcher and he did great. It can be done, but the training takes time and effort. Not a directive from the Board.
Posted 14 December 2019 - 03:36 AM
Managers should train all players who express an interest in pitching. No player should pitch in a game until he/she can throw strikes fairly consistently. It is expected that with additional training most/all pitchers should be able to throw strikes by mid-season.
Each pitcher in each game is limited to their max pitches allowed or three innings whichever comes first.
No pitcher can pitch in two/three (you pick one) games in a row.
Managers are encouraged to play each player in both the infield and outfield each game. Exception: players deemed to be a safety hazard should not play the infield until additional fielding instruction is provided.
It is expected that with the additional instruction most/all players will be capable of playing in the infield by mid-season.
I suggest doing a few internet searches on minor league local rules, there are plenty of them out there that you could use for ideas.
Posted 14 December 2019 - 07:19 PM
For what its worth, the local rules we use for participation in Minors are as follows. We also limit pitch count to 50 in the early part of the season.
Reply to this topic
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users